Reeb made his literary debut with the short story collection The Salt Hour (2011), which earned widespread acclaim for its restrained emotional power. His first novel, Lightfall (2014), a meditation on grief set in a decaying coastal fishing town, established him as a distinctive new voice in American fiction. He followed it with the critically praised The Cartographer's Daughter (2017) and A Winter Arithmetic (2020), the latter a National Book Award finalist. His most recent novel, The Quiet Machinery (2023), examines technology and human connection in near-future America.
Reeb's stories have appeared in The New Yorker, Harper's, and The Paris Review. He currently lives in coastal Maine, where he teaches creative writing and continues to work on his next book.